Two little things I found today while searching the web.
Julian Serrato was named College Soccer News 3rd Team All Freshman. His stats were not that amazing, but I believe he started every game on a team ranked throughout the year, so that gets you something right there. Let's not forget he was a National Team Club player so he obviously has talent. And remember, Baggio's numbers were not that great before his break out year.
Also, College Soccer news has UIC finishing #12 in the nation, and are #12 in the NSCAA, and #14 in Soccer Times. Still wonder what would have happened with a healthy Jovan!